No song - no matter how strongly socially or politically motivated - can ever actually change anything. It is not its purpose.
From the"Internationale" (Eugène Pottier, 1871) to "Imagine" (John Lennon, 1971), from "They Dance Alone" to "Free Nelson Mandela", the most incisive, perceptive, provacative songs have - at best - raised consciousness, galvanised, inspred, been present on the frontlines of protest, on the battle field, at the barricades of struggle and strike; the voice accompanying the banners, posters, flags.
But in themselves, the songs and anthems of social/political comment, protest and resistance can change nothing.
What they constitute is a wake-up, a call to arms. They urge "We the People" to Get Up, Stand Up and DO SOMETHING!; to take responsibility, without which the word democracy is just a word that means nothing.
Neil Young's "Rockin in the Free World" is as perfect an example as I can find to serve as an eloquent soundtrack for this photograph and everything it represents and evokes.
As I do not need the work of Michael Moore to show me what is going on, I only learned this week that he used it frequently to soundtrack his 2004 film, "Fahrenheit 9/11". It proves, I guess, how the powerful message of this song has swelled to embrace causes that at stake in societies far beyond the shores of the United States.
Young's simple acoustic solo version, with his plaintive voice is human, sad, poignant. His electric version is insistent, loud and angry. Each version is both a damning indictment and a rousing anthem to change our attitudes and behaviour towards these human beings fallen into a distress which, with fortune -or fortunes - we others manage to avoid.
"There but for fortune
Go You and I".....
......................The Street, Planet Earth.
15 comments:
Looking... Looking.... I can't even remember which one, but in Greek Philosophy 101 almost three decades ago now, I read that the mission of the poets was to encourage thinking, or some such... And ... I like Mike Moore, because with the overflow of information these days, I personally need to the strong stuff once in a while because I've become jaded/callous/uncaring/can't-be-bothered in my old age, Mile. I love the recent rush of good docos instigated by him, too.
Oh, can I advertise a mini quizTEXT here?
Neil Young`s words say it all don`t they. By the way, he`s Canadian, rather than American. I think it`s time to change the theme of today`s popular music again.
And I`m not getting tired of seeing that picture. It`s everywhere....this shame on us, the human race.
tea
xo
Indeed he is Canadian, as I've always known. You can be rightly proud of him, Tea and all those other great artists who crossed the border from Canada. And then there's Shania Twain....
Meg, I have to say, M.Moore is pretty out on his own when it comes to raising awareness of the masses, but I've certain reservations about him. But in any case, we don't have to like or dislike if we can appreciate that he's doing something worthwhile, which he is.
IF YOU DON'T KNOW THIS SONG, OR YOU'D LIKE TO HEAR IT AGAIN, JUST GO TO RUTH's at
ruth-boofie.blogspot.com
She has put it in there, like I'd have liked to do, but ......
Ruth you ARE a SUPERSTAR!!!!
http://diamondsonthesoul.blog.com/
Hopefully this is my link...set up original blog...but couldnt access it myself then went to help desk and they very kindly sent me a link...and that became two blogs Audrey...its beyond my understanding of the technical but Im learning... this link should allow access...
More important... that since your original entry a few days ago my life has been enriched by action...Its easy to believe yet not act.......and the difference is immense..
What Ive so far read of the poem..real experience and so thought provoking...to go through days, months perhaps without hearing your own name....
This run through my head the day I observed others reactions to the homeless one who touched me so deeply .. a biblical passage..not written specifically for the homeless but could just as easily been so..and so long ago.. not word for word here but...
Without beauty, without majesty
We saw him
No looks to attract our eyes
One despised and rejected by men
Yet our were the sins he bore...........
When genuine gratitude calls you an angel its not much to ask in return "whats your name?" followed by "Your welcome"
Its much easier than I had imagined!!
And one Neil Young song I somehow missed..been buying his music since I was a young thing all of fifteen...must visit Ruths blog..
And thanks for the gentle wake up prod
And of course the last quote, "There but for fortune" was a Phil Ochs song. Now there was another real commentator on the U.S. It's too bad he died by his own hand back in the 70's. He'd have had plenty to write about in these times.
Mile, I'm an old lady with bad eye sighs, sooooo, without wishing to intrude on your artistic considerations, please don't use those tiny fonts... I have a headache....
Hi:):):)
I am back.I will post a review about IFFK 2006 on Monday.Good day & nice weekend.
Hope you r fine.If posiible see"Volver"& El violin.They r very good movies.
Aw shucks MS; you make me blush. I was just lucky that the song was on a very easy to use music site!No computer Whizz me! The words speak for themselves even without the music.
Rx
Hi
Please come back to my site again. I wrote something but soon after I finished I realized it was too long to put here.
Dear mile stones,
Thank you for visiting and your comments!
To move my text over here I think you can just do the "Copy" -> "Paste" and include my text (or codes) in the "cite" tags. I'm glad to have it on your blog!
PS: Have you seen the footer of my page? There's a Creative Commons license link. Just copy anything you would like to have from my site. You are always welcomed.
Stewart - I have been giving this some thought and am still trying to decide just where Mr Young thinks of as the 'Free World'. Surely he can't mean the U.S. of A. I suppose it could possibly be Canada but since a number of countries (including Canada & the UK) seem to be bound by the American yoke then surely he must have been speaking metaphorically.
It would be nice to think that such a place actually existed. I suppose it is probably just a state of mind.
Reg, I'm ready for you on this one, although I'm surprised you need it.
It is nothing but bitter irony, throwing back this absurd label which was so beloved of the Reagan & Bush presidencies back in the 80s, when the song was written. You are well aware of Bush-the-Younger's continuing love affair with the use of the f-word. He says 'freedom' more often than he even says 'god'. Today, the word 'shopping' could perhaps be substituted for 'Rockin' & those of us who are cynics & sceptics could use it to explain one of the real reasons for invasions of Iraq, wars on terror, homeland security, etc. His verses are meant to illuminate to what extent the Free World is a chimera, a fantasy, a lie. Gotta go now, got rockin to keep on doin! Stay warm!
I conheço a pessoa da foto é um traficante/consumidor de droga caido em desgraça que perdeu as pernas durante uma noite ressaca. Vendia droga aos meus colegas de faculdade isto em meados dos anos 80.
J.
Is it still posssible to post comments here?
Post a Comment